Australia: most liveable for whom?
The Australian city of Melbourne
has recently been voted as the world’s most liveable city for the fourth year
in a row. The Economist Intelligence Unit’s annual liveability survey had
Melbourne leading the top 10 cities, which also included Vienna, Vancouver,
Toronto, Adelaide, Calgary, Sydney, Helsinki, Perth, and Auckland.
Indeed, Melbourne is certainly an
easy city to live in from a material perspective according to the survey’s
criteria: healthcare, education, stability, culture and environment and infrastructure.
In matters of Christian faith, however, there are a number of challenges which
are not considered by the liveability survey.
The Council for Christian
Education in Schools, also known as Access Ministries, runs Christian Special
Religious Instruction (SRI) on behalf of 12 denominations using volunteer
instructors in the state of Victoria’s government schools. In 2011, religious
instructors were present in 70 per cent of public primary schools in Victoria. This
number has declined in recent years in the face of a relentless campaign – at
times resembling a witch-hunt – by lobby groups determined to drive all
religious instruction from state schools. Though Christian groups face the
greatest challenge in this way, they are not alone among the faiths; other
faith communities also participate in parallel religious instruction programs,
though to a lesser degree, reflecting their smaller numbers.
Another area of concern for many
Christians relates to the abortion debate. Statistics suggest that around one third
of Australian women will have an abortion in their lifetime. In 2008, the then
Victorian State Labor Government passed the Abortion Law Reform Act,
decriminalising abortion and opening up abortion clinics in Victoria for women
who are up to 24 weeks pregnant. Abortion after 24 weeks is legal, but isn't
commonly performed. The incoming conservative coalition government elected in
2010 was divided on the question of abortion and during its term in power
anti-abortion activists among its members were unable to wind back the Abortion
Law Reform Act.
On 29 November, Victorian State
elections were held for both houses, resulting in a strong swing to centre-left
parties. The incoming Labor government under Premier-elect Daniel Andrews has
signalled that there will be some tough times ahead for people of faith.
During its last term of office,
and during the recent electoral campaign, the Victorian Labor Party indicated
that it planned to amend equal opportunity legislation if it won back power to
make it harder for religious organisations to discriminate against employees on
the basis of their faith and sexual orientation. Labor is proposing to remove existing
exemptions for Christian and other faith-based schools.
In a recent demonstration of
unity, Anglican, Baptist, Catholic, Coptic, Lutheran, and Presbyterian leaders
expressed strong opposition to Labor’s intended restrictions on employment in
religious organisations. This is likely to be the beginning of an ongoing
struggle.
Although the incoming Labor
government will be able to govern comfortably in its own right, it will be able
to count on the support of several members of both lower and upper houses from
minor parties as it pursues its policies on religious matters. The Victorian
Greens won their first ever seat in the lower house, supplementing their
existing three seats in the upper house. One of the latter, Member of the
Legislative Council Sue Pennicuik, declared in July 2014: “Public schools are
secular and so religious proselytising and distribution of religious material
has no place.” The Christian Special Religious Instruction activities in
government schools look like being under even more scrutiny and pressure in
years to come.
In a development which most
Christians in Victoria consider an embarrassment, the recent elections also
witnessed success for the Sex Party, which won a seat in the Legislative
Council. The elected member, Fiona Patten, called for the abolition of tax
breaks for religious organisations, declaring that “Organised religion … runs
gambling, bookshops, real estate and other businesses that are exempt from
taxation simply because they claim some link to a higher being, encourage
people to take up prayer and generally ‘advance religion’.” The party wants to
expand age-appropriate sex education in schools, decriminalise cannabis for
personal use, strengthen freedom of information laws, and increase people's
right to privacy.
The coming years will determine
whether Melbourne proves to be as “liveable” for people of faith as it supposedly
is for those of no faith.
This article
first appeared in "Evangelicals Now",
January 2015, p10.